« The Pantry Alphabet: S | Main | Recipe for no-cook blueberry apple soup {vegetarian} »

Recipe for grilled portobello mushroom and goat cheese sandwich with smoked pepper spread

Grilled portobello mushroom and goat cheese sandwich with smoked pepper spread, from The Perfect Pantry.

When my husband Ted and I acquired a panini press last year, we spent the first few months smooshing anything we could find into beautiful, Italian-style flat sandwiches. (Easier and more sanitary than running over them with the car, but you get the idea.) Later, influenced by the wonderful Panini Happy blog, we began to consider the panini press as a more versatile kitchen tool.

With the addition of waffle plates, we celebrated our first Wafflepalooza last summer, but overall it's the grill plates that get the most workout. For dishes like this portobello mushroom and goat cheese sandwich, the panini press is perfect. It holds four burger-size mushroom caps, and cooks and flattens them in minutes. No heating of the grill or broiler, though either would give the mushrooms the "meaty" flavor that tricks carnivores into thinking they're really eating hamburgers. Use the freshest goat cheese you can find (my friend Christine's creamy homemade chevre paired so well with the mushrooms), and don't skip the smoked pepper spread that sets this sandwich apart.

Grilled portobello mushrooms take the place of burgers in this sandwich.

Grilled portobello mushroom and goat cheese sandwich with smoked pepper spread {vegetarian}

From the pantry, you'll need: goat cheese, mayonnaise, ketchup, fresh thyme or parsley, piment d'Espelette, Sriracha sauce, kosher salt, olive oil.

Makes 4 sandwiches.


For the spread:
3 Tbsp mayonnaise
1 Tbsp ketchup
1 tsp fresh chopped thyme or parsley leaves
1/4 tsp piment d'Espelette (or smoked paprika)
2-4 drops Sriracha sauce, to taste
Pinch of kosher salt

For the sandwiches:
8 slices crusty bread
4 portobello mushroom caps
2 Tbsp olive oil
Kosher salt and fresh black pepper
4 tsp goat cheese
4 1/4-inch slices ripe tomato
1 cup baby arugula leaves


Whisk together all of the spread ingredients in a small mixing bowl. Cover, and refrigerate until ready to use (can be made a day ahead).

Heat a panini press or stovetop grill pan, or an outdoor grill. When the pan is hot, toast the bread until light grill marks appear. Remove and set aside.

Paint the mushroom caps on both sides with olive oil, and sprinkle with salt and pepper. Place in your panini press (or grill pan, weighted down slightly with a brick wrapped in aluminum foil, or with a second cast iron pan), and grill for 4 minutes, or until the mushrooms are flattened and cooked through. Remove from the press or grill and set aside.

Assemble the sandwiches: Spread one side of 4 slices of bread with goat cheese. Spread one side of the other 4 slices with the smoked pepper spread. Divide the arugula between the 4 sandwiches, on top of the goat cheese. Top the arugula with the mushrooms and tomato slices. Close the sandwiches, press down slightly, and cut in half with a serrated bread knife.

Serve at room temperature, or let cool slightly, then wrap the sandwiches in plastic wrap and chill to serve later.

[Printer-friendly recipe.]

More goat cheese:
Grilled vegetable and goat cheese puff pastry tart with zucchini, mushrooms, peppers and onions, from The Perfect Pantry
Tomato and goat cheese bruschetta, from The Perfect Pantry
Smoked salmon and spinach goat cheese strata, from Gluten-free Goddess
Rotini with portobello mushrooms, caramelized onions, and goat cheese, from Big Flavors from a Tiny Kitchen

Grill meaty portobello mushroom caps for these ultra-juicy sandwiches, and slather on some smoked pepper spread for extra flavor.

Disclosure: The Perfect Pantry earns a few pennies on purchases made through the Amazon.com links in this post. Thank you for supporting this site when you start your shopping here.


That sounds like an excellent combo! Then again, goat cheese seems to go well with everything. :)

J3nn, my friend's homemade goat cheese was a real treat in this sandwich. I love it with mushrooms.

Love all the flavors in this sammie -- have made something similar with grilled peppers. Makes me want one for breakfast :) I love my panini pan and have been using it a lot for easy grilling lately. Handy things!

I haven't grilled portobello mushrooms in a long time, but always loved their meaty flavor. I've just gotten a grill again, so this is on the menu.

Kellypea, grilled peppers would be a great addition to this already loaded-with-flavor sandwich. I truly wonder now how I ever lived without a panini press, though of course I did, right up until last year!

TW, portobellos are still one of my favorite vegetables to grill. So glad you are back in the grilling world.

This sounds amazing!! Love portabellas. :)

Denise, same here. And I love making this sandwich for our vegetarian friends and kids!

Everything about this sounds fantastic. I have been resisting getting a panini maker because I don't eat a lot of bread, but I bet I could make this on the George Foreman grill.

This sounds like a perfect sandwich to me... makes me think I need to get my griddler out with the grill plates and see what I can "smoosh" with it!

Your sandwich looks delicious, Lydia. We had PBTs at our house the other night: portobellos, bacon and tomato sandwiches. The smoked pepper sauce would have been perfect with them!

Kalyn, I don't eat much bread, either (though Ted loves making panini), but I use the press for chicken breasts, grilled veggies, and yes, the occasional pancake or waffle breakfast.

Patsy, I love my Griddler! with this sandwich, you grill the bread and mushrooms separately, but you could do it as a gooey panino, too.

Christine, bacon makes everything better!

Yum! I gotta get me some of the "piment d'Espelette!" (and dust off my panini maker!)

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.